The REAL Message Behind the Passage of Health Care Reform

One of the wonders of living in the modern Web-based world is that we have access to so much information in near real-time. Nowhere was this more clear to me than during the recent Washington drama around health care reform. To quote the old bromide, we actually got to watch the process of sausage being made in excruciating detail.

I say that because I don’t believe that what went on in Washington over the last several months on this issue was much different than the type of horse trading that’s traditionally been part of the process required to pass this kind of large, game-changing legislation. The difference is we got to watch it not just on TV, as we’ve done for a generation, or on the Internet, as we’ve done for the last 15 years, but in real-time with social media added in.

Add in the fact that because the protagonists in this battle have become so media savvy themselves,  and the fact that this was played on center stage across a variety of old and new media was in itself a gamechanger. So many of the comments and positions taken were no more than grandstanding for not only the cameras but the Twitterstreams as well. So much of the drama and passion was introduced for the benefit of the players themselves and their reelection hopes, rather than to add value to the conversation.

Furthermore, the conversation was not between the players with opposing points of view, but directed outwards through the media to the public. So much hysteria was introduced–from death squads to the death of the American way of life–yet very few of the people arguing either position understood what exactly was being proposed or how this might impact them and others in the future. Lots of heat–not much light.

Interestingly, what the Republicans condemned as potentially devastating socialism was more narrow in scope than a health reform package proposed in the 1960s by a Republican president named Richard Nixon. What the Democrats insisted had to be done to save our health care system is not nearly enough to solve the issues in front of us. It’s hard to understand how we can be so backwards when we have examples of working health insurance systems like the e111 in Europe.

Without having seen all the details, the one thing I can be sure of is that the bill is not perfect. That would be impossible. It will of course cause some problems that don’t exist today, break some things while fixing others, cause issues or financial harm to some people. However, to not move ahead at all and wait for perfection makes no sense whatsoever. The bill *does* fix many of the issues faced by ordinary Americans today and it is an important step forward. It will necessarily be argued, debated, amended and updated over time as have all omnibus pieces of legislation, including Social Security, Medicare and our tax laws.  In fact, one of the provisions of the bill is to fix the “doughnut hole” in Medicare coverage inadvertently created by previous legislation. It breaks down the ghetto of preexisting conditions and eliminates the arbitrary dollar caps for insurance coverage.

The bill itself is a move in the right direction. However, the process of getting there was a major step backward. One of the casualties of this new culture of observation is that it’s too easy to focus on public statements and rhetoric and less on the back and forth negotiation based on ongoing relationships that makes any complex organization work effectively. Instead, we saw people on all sides dig in and defend their positions at all costs–refusing to publicly acknowledge others’ perspectives and creating a mass hysteria that was totally unwarranted.

In simple terms, we saw a continuation of a phenomenon that is becoming a major problem for this country: extreme polarization and very little outreach and effort to work together for the common good. We saw, yet again,  much too much blue and much too much red and virtually no purple. That’s the real message I fear behind this effort. To quote the first senator from Illinois elected to the presidency, “A country divided against itself cannot stand.”

Let’s hope for more purple going forward.

This entry was posted in Current Affairs and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The REAL Message Behind the Passage of Health Care Reform

  1. Linda…nice post. The GOP never showed up in good faith to support reform–they expressed the desire to block in Obamba’s agenda in any way that they could before Obama was even inaugurated. Given the intransigence of the GOP towards reform, the Dems did the best they could to move things forward. Contrary to predictions, Armageddon has not occurred today. The Dow is up nearly 60 points (as I write this) today, so, the business world doesn’t seem too frightened about the legislation. Democrat Dave

  2. Kathy Klotz-Guest says:

    Good points, Linda. The bill isn’t perfect for sure but we need to start somewhere. What fired people up about Obama’s election is that we believed in a different kind of Washington where people on opposite sides could work together in civil ways for the good of the American people. Prima facie – given media coverage – the rancor in government just seems to be getting worse. This type of behavior would RIGHTLY get people fired in the private sector. Little wonder most Americans – the purple silent majority – are so disgusted. But it’s time for this majority to stop being silent and demand better of our elected representatives.

  • Upcoming Events

  • What’s New

    Article: "How Great Consultants Can Stand Up and Stand Out" by Linda Popky on Women in Consulting - Read article!

    Article: "5 Ways to Make Organizational Friction Work for You" by Linda Popky on MENGonline - @popky #MENGonline #Marketing - Read article.

    Podcast: Interview of Linda Popky about Using Friction to Improve Your Marketing by Gene Hammett on Leaders in the Trenches.

    SAC® Press Release: "Strong Economy Creates Long-Term Growth Opportunities for Smart Businesses" – Read release.

    Podcast: Linda Popky interviews Dan Janal who tells us why the changes in the publishing industry offer outstanding opportunities for business people who have something to say. - Listen.


    Take our Marketing Above the Noise Assessment.

    Video: Just a Moment for Marketing: Mocha on Marketing: It Doesn't Smell Right. If it doesn't smell right, it just isn't right. – View the video.

    NEW eBOOK: Top of Mind: 101 Insights to Transform Your Business
    Purchase PDF or ePub book.
    Top of Mind

    Book Video Trailer How can your message be heard in today's crowded, chaotic environment? Learn more about Linda Popky's new book, Marketing Above the Noise: Achieve Strategic Advantage with Marketing that Matters, in this short video trailer.

    Harvard Business Review: "Identify the Marketing Metrics That Actually Matter" by Linda J. Popky - Read article

  • Read Our Blog

  • Subscribe to the Top of Mind Thursday Newsletter

    Free articles download with sign up
  • Marketing Above the Noise

    Introducing Dynamic Market Leverage™, an approach to help cut through the clutter, stand out, and effectively build business.

    Marketing Above The Noise

    What's Inside Available in Hardcover and eBook formats